Did any particular actors or characters really impress this season?
STEPHANIE: Grant Gustin was a shining star the entire season. And Carlos Valdes definitely impressed in a breakout role.
CRAIG: I have to be completely honest here and say something that I now regret: When Grant Gustin was first cast as Barry Allen, I was unenthused. I hated him as Sebastian on Glee, and clearly I wasn’t aware yet of the range of his talents. Seeing him as Barry makes me think “Sebastian who?” It’s dangerous to confuse an actor with a character, and Grant Gustin’s Barry is about as different from Sebastian Smythe as one can get. I think it’s a testament to the talent, and the time and effort that Gustin puts in to bring us Barry Allen on this show, as well as his alter ego. So, Grant, if you are reading this: My personal apologies for underestimating you. You were fantastic.
There was a lot of talent across the board, really, but I’d feel bad if I don’t mention two people in particular: Tom Cavanagh, who proves that funny people play the best villains, giving us so many layers to Wells that even though he would do such bad things, you questioned your hate for him just like Barry would have. And then there’s Jesse L. Martin, who makes EVERYTHING better. I don’t mean to judge the notion that The Flash is on The CW, but I’m constantly amazed that actors of their caliber are on this show. (See also: Mark Hamill and Victor Garber).
MATT: Grant Gustin was a joy throughout the year. I wasn’t sure when he was cast as Barry if he would be right for the part. Now, I can’t picture anyone else in the role. He’s so good in the role, and I enjoy what they’ve done with it so much, that this is even the basis for how I’d like to see Spider-Man done. Gustin’s Barry Allen might just be the best live-action Peter Parker out there. I really like Cisco, though I am glad that they gave the character more depth. He’s audience stand-in geekiness can be fun, but it can also wear thin. And just when you think you can kind of write Cisco off, they give Carlos Valdes some terrifically meaty things to play and he steps up. Pairing him with Joe West was a superb choice, and then playing Cisco and Harrison Wells off of each other brought many unexpected treats. And then, there’s Joe. I was a fan of Jesse L. Martin before the show, but it’s not hard for me to say that his Joe could very well be my favorite character in the entirety of the DCwU. He is the heart, and what he brings to Barry’s life as a father figure is truly astounding. They way Martin and Gustin connect frequently causes my heart to swell.
DEREK: I want to give props to Carlos Valdes and Cisco for so competently growing as a character — I wasn’t actually fond of him at first, especially not like others were. But it didn’t take long for him to hit his stride and become one of the best. In total agreement about Grant Gustin; he has been such a revelation, and he’s found a balance in this young version of Barry without coming off as a precocious wunderkind or overly whiny. He’s not one-sided or gimmicky as a hero; Barry loves the fun parts of his hero life and he’s sad at all the appropriate moments. Like Matt, I think Gustin brings a distinct “Peter Parker-esque” quality that I’ve longed to see in a live-action Spider-Man show. Of course, The Flash’s spin is that he’s not overly angsty and he does get what he wants once he’s earned it.
I, too, found Jesse L. Martin to be a breakout. Joe brings a distinct level of humanity that we don’t always get in a universe where everyone turns into a costumed hero. Joe is wise and loving, but he’s not perfect; this season showed the fault of his overprotectiveness with Iris, which he had to learn to overcome at the end. And he had the most realistic reaction to being kidnapped by a mind-controlling gorilla you’ll ever see on TV. And best of all, Martin does some of the best teary-eyed acting ever. Eddie Thawne also clicked much better than I expected, even though Rick Cosnett didn’t get much to do until the end of the season. The show made sure we appreciated Eddie’s worth, even though he was predominately a pawn. He could have just been “the other guy” in the main love triangle, or Cosnett’s perfect villain-voice could have brought him to the logical bad guy conclusion. Instead, he was a genuinely great guy who projected a positive message that even the “little guys,” or the ones told they won’t amount to anything, can be the biggest heroes.
Any characters that didn’t work as well?
DEREK: I think Ronnie has something to offer, but I found myself mostly bored when his character was at the forefront. In the Firestorm two-parter, I was far more interested in Caitlin’s arc and Professor Stein, while Robbie Amell’s pretty standard “young heroic good-looking dude” didn’t offer much unique material. Beyond that, many of the metahumans fell flat. It’s not good when the team of baddies in “Rogue Air” was mostly made up of nearly indistinguishable skinny young white guys who were evil because they could be. Doug Jones was also wasted as Deadbolt, and Peekaboo never felt like the fully-formed character her backstory was suggesting, though I’d be more interested to see her again than the other surviving metas.
CRAIG: Linda Park was kind of a diversion, but she gave Iris a girlfriend to hang out with a little bit, so that was nice. Again, I wasn’t too fond of some of the villains-of-the-week, either.
STEPHANIE: I struggled to connect to Iris as a character. Nothing against Candice Patton (she’s immensely talented), but Iris came across as too oblivious and wide-eyed. I just wanted to yell at her to figure things out already. In addition, we’ve seen this type of oblivious love interest / superhero sort-of-sidekick so many times before that nothing about her seemed unique.
MATT: I’m still a bit torn on Caitlin as a character, as well as not completely sold on Ronnie. (Though, again, we got a live-action Firestorm. What?!) Again, I think Iris was left with little to do throughout the season. Now that she’s in on the secret, that should change. Especially with the burden of Eddie’s loss.
Tatiana
September 30, 2015 at 5:24 pm
So many great points being made here. I love how close Flash sticks to the spirit of the comics, and the episodes where they parallel the personal relationships to the scifi elements are golden. I’m also so happy that Iris knows the truth now and can be integrated into the main plot. I feel like Westallen as the romantic backbone of the story can only get better from here, but like you said, it doesn’t overwhelm the plot of the story which is so important.
Craig Byrne
September 30, 2015 at 5:27 pm
Personally speaking, now that Iris knows what’s up, I think there’s nothing stopping that if that’s where they want to go… obviously being The Flash, it’ll happen eventually.
Rei
September 30, 2015 at 5:32 pm
This was a great round table. It’s awesome to see everyone’s opinions laid out. I’m all about Barry and his relationships with the Wests, so my favorite episodes are the usuals: 1.09, 1.15, 1.20, 1.21, 1.23. But if I had to pick an underrated episode… I know the crossover in 1.08 isn’t that exactly, but I think it was the best use of Arrow characters in The Flash all season long. The two worlds clashed beautifully and seeing some of Barry’s subconscious resentments (against Joe for ‘imprisoning’ Henry and against Eddie for ‘stealing’ Iris) was both enlightening and shocking. Even though his anger was unfair, of course, it helped to make him more well-rounded.
Halberdier17
October 1, 2015 at 9:02 pm
There was a point where Arrow got three weeks ahead of the Flash. The episode when Oliver joined the League of Assassins they did a three week time skip because Oliver was training.
Wintgster55
October 2, 2015 at 9:49 am
See, I think that some of the writing for Iris was off..and it would’ve been nice if they had her in the main plot more…but I liked that she had her own arc throughout the season with journalism. Showed character development which is more important. Plus if she was in the A plot more she would have been a supporter of Barry’s story instead of his equal